I know I am a little late posting but I went with the Rhino Rack. I didn't go with the off brand ones on Amazon just to try and prevent a knock off product that wasn't well produced.
I encountered two problems with this.
1) The mounting hardware on one connection failed while installing and a rivet nut popped through the part. I couldn't order just this part so I had to order a second whole unit and swap the part out then send that unit back. Thanks to ordering the Rhino Rack from Amazon it was easy and quick. I recommend checking those rivet nuts before you install and make sure they will take a load or else it could pop out while you are at speed.
2) Their wind fairing connected to the rack itself that you see in pictures and while at speed only after a couple trips to and from work, the hardware holding it on popped off. It came with this configuration: Bolt, rubber washer, fairing, mount, and then a nut. This was not a locking nut so with vibration, two of the five bolts came loose and popped out at speed. I would suggest either using Loctite or switching to locknuts to prevent this. I have yet to do this though so cannot provide input on which is better.
Problems aside I love this. It does provide quite a bit of wind noise and the fairing does do a great job at decreasing that noise, but I decided to take this off. It is currently hanging in my garage until my next trip, if I even put it back on.
I also took it off because I do not want to risk someone coming along and taking it off as I do not live in the greatest of areas.
Below are some pictures:
