I just got new mats so I'll let you know my experience!
When I first got my Sonic it came with the Chevy all season rubber mats which I liked but my heel wore through after about a year. I replaced them with Weathertech mats, not the more expensive floor liner mats but the less expensive all weather floor mats because the less expensive floor mats actually covered the dead pedal better.
The first set of Weathertech all weather floor mats lasted about a year before they wore through, when they did I got a second set which also lasted about a year.
The third time I got Huskyliner floor mats and I love them. They are not made out of a soft rubber so they should last much longer, they are more like a flexible plastic - kinda like the flexible plastic phone cases. And the Huskyliner covers the dead pedal all the way vs the Weathertech floor liner which only halfway covers it.
All of that to say I'm very pleased so far with the Huskyliner
